1 Blockmodels
نویسنده
چکیده
Professionals can be rewarded in different ways. The most common type of reward is provided by the market, that is, by successfully selling one’s products or services to consumers. In professional fields dealing with the production of knowledge, art, et cetera, market success is usually just one type of reward for professionals and not necessarily the most important one. Especially recognition by peers and financing by the government is important here. Because governments tend to use several schemes for allocating money to a particular sector, we usually deal with systems of rewards. This paper visualizes and examines the system of rewards for visual artists, installed by the Dutch national government in the period 1984-2005. Because this system includes several subsidy schemes involving different stakeholders in the allocation of subsidies – consumers, institutional experts and artists themselves – we expect it to be segmented, viz., different types of schemes will favour different types of art and artists as hypothesized by Diana Crane (‘Reward systems in art, science, and religion.’ American Behavioral Scientist, 19 (1976), 719-734). In addition, I expect that the Matthew Effect, introduced by Robert K. Merton (Science 159 (1968) 5, 56-63) will be operative, which predicts a concentration of rewards among a small group of artists, because notably the institutional experts and artists involved in the allocation of subsidies will take previous awards of subsidies as a sign of artistic quality.
منابع مشابه
Clustering via Content-Augmented Stochastic Blockmodels
Much of the data being created on the web contains interactions between users and items. Stochastic blockmodels, and other methods for community detection and clustering of bipartite graphs, can infer latent user communities and latent item clusters from this interaction data. These methods, however, typically ignore the items’ contents and the information they provide about item clusters, desp...
متن کاملNetwork Construction Methods for the Simulation of Stochastic Blockmodels DRAFT
This working paper summarizes a number of methods to construct networks represented as stochastic blockmodels. The different methods are developed to obtain networks that vary in relevant network measures, e.g., density, outdegrees, indegrees, degree variances.
متن کاملA Frequency-based Stochastic Blockmodel
We propose a frequency-based infinite relational model (FIRM), which takes into account the frequency of relation whereas stochastic blockmodels ignore frequency. We also derive a variational inference method for the FIRM to apply to a large dataset. Experimental results show that the FIRM gives better clustering results than a stochastic blockmodel on a dataset which has the frequency of relat...
متن کاملVariable selection for (realistic) stochastic blockmodels
Stochastic blockmodels provide a convenient representation of relations between communities of nodes in a network. However, they imply a notion of stochastic equivalence that is often unrealistic for real networks, and they comprise large number of parameters that can make them hardly interpretable. We discuss two extensions of stochastic blockmodels, and a recently proposed variable selection ...
متن کاملStructural Analysis in Multi-Relational Social Networks
Modern social networks often consist of multiple relations among individuals. Understanding the structure of such multi-relational network is essential. In sociology, one way of structural analysis is to identify different positions and roles using blockmodels. In this paper, we generalize stochastic blockmodels to Generalized Stochastic Blockmodels (GSBM) for performing positional and role ana...
متن کاملBuilding stochastic blockmodels
The literature devoted to the construction of stochastic blockmodels is relatively rare compared to that of the deterministic variety. In this paper, a general definition of a stochastic blockmodel is given and a number of techniques for building such blockmodels are presented. In the statistical approach, the likelihood ratio statistic provides a natural index to evaluate the fit of the model ...
متن کامل